The North/South Divide

The Viking Web Site of BBC Radio in Yorkshire

THE NORTH/SOUTH DIVIDE

Did the Vikings Help Create It ?

Politicians don’t like to acknowledge that there exists such a phenomenon as a ‘north/south divide’. They fear to admit its existence, seeing it as divisive and running counter to the ‘one nation’ principle. They try hard to persuade us away from such thinking, often citing evidence such as “…the number of millionaires in the north”, or examples of large institutions relocating their headquarters from the south-east to northern cities. They are at pains to minimalise factors such as income, property value and life-chance differentials and constantly push the idea that these are narrowing. On Budget Day 1989 Margaret Thatcher declared that the north/south divide had gone. More recently, Prime Minister Tony Blair has echoed this sentiment. There are many dimensions that can be analysed and brought into play by those who argue that the north/south divide does remain a reality. Lower wages and higher unemployment feature prominently, along with property values.

But do these arguments, by focusing on post-Industrial Revolution economic indicators, miss the real point ? Isn’t there a more fundamental division, one rooted in history, culture, tradition, language and genetics ? If so, we can’t escape taking into account the role played by Scandinavian settlers in the north. This is not the only analysis that can be presented, of course, and the geographical location of the north/south boundary is itself problematic. Is the line to be drawn, for example, on geological and geomorphological criteria ? These can account for differences in landscape and land utilisation which had a bearing on economic activity and social organisation going right back into prehistory. If this is the case, then the classic highland/lowland division on a Tees/Exe line would seem to indicate a boundary. But such a demarcation would not encompass ‘the north’ as most people understand the term. It is possible to establish alternative lines of demarcation, on different criteria.

Perhaps the physical demarcation is less important than the intangible sense of ‘northern consciousness’. This seems to have had its first stirrings as the major Anglo-Saxon kingdoms began to emerge from the mosaic of petty kingdoms and chiefdoms that had developed as a consequence of post-4th century Germanic invasion, immigration and settlement. Much of Anglo-Saxon history concerns the struggles for supremacy between the southern, Saxon kingdoms and the northern, Anglian kingdoms, with frequent contributions in one direction or the other from the Angles of ‘middle-England’ in the form of Mercia. Bede, in his historical writings in the early 8th century, saw contemporary politics in terms of ‘Northumbrian’ and ‘Southumbrian’ power blocks, carrying the implication that “the north” starts somewhere just to the south of Yorkshire.

Helen Jewell * wrote:

Later, comparisons began to be made about the actual peoples, and the characterising of northerners as ferocious, obstinate and unyielding began to creep into southern chronicles……This perspective derives from and illustrates the fact that the balance of power has usually favoured the south: the northeners were obstinate mainly because they would not do as the south dictated” (p. 208).

If this was the situation at the beginning of the Viking Age in England, then it can only have been reinforced as Scandinavians settled in, and exercised control over, much of northern England. The Vikings who setttled here, it has been argued, did so at least in part because they wished to escape the growth of centralised royal power in their homelands. Land-hunger and land availability obviously must have played a part but, as in Iceland, it appears that those who came and settled brought with them an in-built resentment of authority imposed from outside, together with qualities of independence and a cherishing of individual freedom. Where they conceded to leadership and gave allegiance, this was largely by choice and based on the personal qualities that were perceived in a leader for a particular purpose – and only for as long as those qualities remained demonstrable. A leader who became unsuccessful in war, trade or politics, would cease to be entitled (and would not expect to be entitled) to hold a position of authority for long.

In the Treaty of Wedmore, whereby the West Saxon king, Alfred the Great, and the Viking leader, Guthorm or Guthrum, agreed to partition England by a line running roughly from London to Chester, northern and eastern England came under Scandinavian law and custom. This area became known as The Danelaw. It was in The Danelaw that the majority of Vikings settled and intermarried – or into which they introduced their families – to be followed by other immigrants from the Scandinavian homelands. Though the southern and eastern parts of The Danelaw were soon recovered by Alfred’s successors, the region we generally regard as ‘the north’ (centred largely on the Viking Kingdom of York) remained long under Scandinavian control and influence. This resulted in the emergence of an Anglo-Scandinavian population, with marked effects on language, culture and genetic composition. An anonymous church chronicle, which came into the possession of John of Wallingford, who lived in the 13th century, tells how the people of the region around York

“…had much intercourse with the Danes and intermarried with them, and became like them in speech…”.

William of Malmesbury wrote of the Vikings and their Anglo-Scandinavian descendants in northern England:

“….they were a people free-born and freely educated, and unable to tolerate the cruelty of any prince…..they had been taught by their ancestors either to be free or die…”

The northern Danelaw long remained restive and resentful of southern authority. The ‘Viking flame’ was always likely to re-ignite and pose a threat to the southern powers and, at best, southern possession of the northern Danelaw remained but tenuous. In AD 933 and again in 1013, the Anglo-Scandinavian population of the north offered no resistance – and probably supported – Danish invasions. The ‘invaders’ were probably not perceived as such in the north; it seems likely that ties of kinship across a Dublin-Yorkshire-Scandinavian axis were more powerful and significant.

The Viking spirit was reinforced by the need to win a much harder living from the land, in harsher, less favourable food- and wealth-producing conditions. As Helen Jewell writes, “Small wonder that northerners see themselves as hard and resilient and regard southerners as effete”. The 11th century saw incidents where northerners expelled the king’s brother-in-law, Tostig, who had been foisted on them as Earl of Northumbria, and King William I’s ‘harrying of the north’, which can hardly have endeared a southern-based monarchy to the northern population! But William should have expected no less than a northern resistance to his rule. He is known to have regarded the northern Danelaw as a region of potential support for any Scandinavian invasion; and (being of Viking descent himself) must have known that the imposition of a feudal system on a population with a tradition of individual freedom and independence would spell trouble. The harshness with which William was forced to impose his authority on the north says something about the depth of feeling amongst the northern people, and about William’s own apprehensions and insecurity about having such a population within his realm.

Northerners’ suspicions of the south, and resentment of the authority which originates from there, seems to have diminished little over the nine and a half centuries since the end of the Viking Age. The Industrial Revolution and its aftermath have been generally commented on in terms of northern hardship and relative poverty, producing profit and wealth for the non-industrial south. In recent decades, the demise of traditional heavy industries of the north, with subsequent economic and social decline, have been seen in stark contrast to the growing affluence and economic development of London and the southern counties.

Perhaps the one 20th century event which was seen as symbolic of southern attitudes to the north was the abolition of the historic Ridings of Yorkshire in 1974. These administrative divisions, established by the Viking Kingdom of York, were powerful symbols of the heritage and history of this region, and had been so for over a thousand years. To many Yorkshire folk, this was seen as an act of political vandalism, confirming the northern perception of the Whitehall mandarins as insensitive, vindictive philistines.

But the flame burns on: The Ridings Society is dedicated to the preservation of awareness of the boundaries, and ultimately the re-establishment, of all three of the ancient administrative divisions; the East Riding Dialect Society begins its Yorkshire Day celebrations with a Declaration of Integrity of the county and its three Ridings – and reinforces this with a reading in Old Norse !

Our Scandinavian-language place names remain as indelible symbols of our past and, despite the efforts of educationists and the media, quite a bit of the Scandinavian vocabulary of our traditional dialects lives on.

Dr. Barrie M. Rhodes, Co-ordinator UK, The Viking Network

* Jewell, Helen M. (1994) The North-south divide: The origins of northern consciousness in England; Manchester University Press, which is acknowledged as the source of much of the commentary in this article.

Click on the orm to return to the Front Page

Last updated: 19 October 2026

This post is also available in: Norwegian Bokmål Danish